Plum’s own collection page says that its Avocado and Argan shampoo is sulphate free and that three other Plum shampoos use SLES, so a brand name on a bottle does not settle the claim. Bare Anatomy makes its statement for every shampoo it sells, Arata describes a cleanser system, and Mamaearth answers the question in a FAQ.
The best sulphate free shampoo among these four is therefore the one whose ingredient list agrees with the claim made for it. Plum, Bare Anatomy and Mamaearth sell bottles of the same size, and Arata sells a smaller one, so size does little to separate them.
What the Mamaearth blog means by sulphate free
Mamaearth’s blog defines a sulphate free shampoo as one without surfactants such as Sodium Lauroyl Sulphate (SLS) and Sodium Laureth Sulphate (SLES). It names Ammonium Lauryl Sulphate (ALS) as another to leave out.
That definition comes from a promotional brand blog. The blog does not cite its claims, and it describes no drawback of sulphate free shampoos.
Because the definition names only three surfactants, the check it supports is narrow. Sarcosinates, betaines and glucosides, which open the Plum and Mamaearth lists, are different names from SLS, SLES and ALS.
Shoppers in a humid city who wash their hair several times a week are the readers most likely to rely on the badge. The badge says what the brand intends, and the list on the label says what is in the bottle.
How each brand words the claim
Each brand words the claim differently, and the same words can mean a FAQ answer, a badge or a range statement. Plum answers it in a product FAQ, and Bare Anatomy puts a badge on the product and states that every shampoo in its range is sulphate free.
Arata describes a surfactant system and labels no single shampoo. Mamaearth gives a FAQ answer with marketing wording around it.
Plum’s collection page adds a detail. It says the Avocado and Argan shampoo is sulphate free, and that its Coconut Milk and Peptides, Hibiscus and Ceramides and Volcanic Minerals shampoos use SLES.
One of those Plum product URLs contains the words sls free, which conflicts with the collection statement.
Smaller mismatches show up elsewhere. A URL for a WOW Skin Science Coconut Milk shampoo and conditioner set says no parabens sulphate, though the text for the set makes no sulphate claim. mCaffeine’s collection page says its Damage Repair Latte Shampoo is free of silicones, sulfates and parabens, but shows no product link or size.
Cleansers named in the ingredient lists
Under the Mamaearth definition, the check is to scan the first lines of the list for SLS, SLES and ALS, and to note any other name built on sulfonate.
Plum names Cocamidopropyl Betaine, Sodium Lauroyl Sarcosinate and Coco Glucoside as its cleansers. Mamaearth’s Onion Shampoo list starts with Onion Seed Water, then Sodium Lauroyl Sarcosinate, Cocamidopropyl Betaine and Cocamide MEA.
Arata is different, and the difference shows in the opening lines. Its list begins with Purified Water, Sodium Lauroyl Methyl Isethionate, Alpha Olefin Sulfonate, Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate and Cocamidopropyl Betaine, and it later includes TEA Dodecylbenzene Sulfonate.
Sulfonate names are not the same words as the three sulphate names in the Mamaearth definition. Arata does not discuss the difference, so the point is an observation about its list and not a statement from the brand.
Claim and list agree in the Plum shampoo
Plum has the most layers of support for a reader with frizzy or wavy hair who wants the sulphate free claim and the list to match. Its product FAQ answers yes to whether the shampoo is sulphate free, the meta description says sulphate and paraben free formula, and the cleansers are readable in the list.
After glycerin, acrylates copolymer and aloe leaf juice, the list reaches avocado oil and argan kernel oil. Plum calls the shampoo curl friendly, which fits frizzy or wavy hair.
The list and the FAQ answer agree with each other, and that agreement is what puts it ahead of the other three. It does not mean the shampoo does anything for hair beyond what Plum says.
Its product URL ends in copy, and the collection statement about other Plum shampoos using SLES sits on the same site. A bottle needs to read Avocado and Argan before the claim applies to it.
A badge and a range wide statement from Bare Anatomy
Bare Anatomy sells the Anti Frizz Shampoo with Rice Protein and Hyaluronic Acid, with a Sulphate Free badge and a statement that all of its shampoos are sulphate free. The brand states frizz control for up to 24 hours.
Named actives are rice protein, hyaluronic acid, coconut milk protein and aloe vera extract. Bare Anatomy also calls the shampoo dermatologically tested, which is a claim and is repeated here as one.
A 91 percent of users figure and the frizz control time both come from a brand consumer trial.
About 30 ingredients are listed for the shampoo, and the full text is on the bottle label.
Bare Anatomy suits a reader who wants an anti frizz shampoo from a brand that makes its sulphate free statement for every shampoo it sells. Next to Plum, the contrast is in the evidence. Plum shows its cleansers in the opening lines of the list, while Bare Anatomy relies on a badge and a range wide statement.
Hair fall focus in the Mamaearth Onion Shampoo
Mamaearth positions its Onion Shampoo with Onion and Plant Keratin for hair fall control, not for frizz. The FAQ for the 250 ml size answers yes to the sulphate free question.
That answer is wrapped in broad wording about being free from all types of harmful chemicals and toxins. The brand also says the shampoo is free of silicones, parabens, mineral oil and dyes.
A full ingredient list is shown, which makes this the easiest of the four to check against the label for a reader whose main worry is hair fall. Its first cleansers use the same two names that open the Plum list, in the opposite order.
Mamaearth says the shampoo is dermatologically tested and refers to a certificate, and that is a claim too. Mamaearth sells the Onion Shampoo in more than one pack size, and the size described here is the 250 ml one.
Sulfonates beside the claim in the Arata shampoo
Arata’s Damage Defence Super Shampoo comes in 200 ml, a smaller bottle than the other three. Arata calls it a gentle, sulphate free surfactant system and positions it for damaged hair and the scalp.
Its collection page labels no individual shampoo sulphate free. A general FAQ line mentions that its sulphate free shampoos cleanse gently, without saying which ones.
Arata gives a 94 percent keratin retention figure from an in vitro test, a result for the formula measured outside the body, and describes the shampoo as derma tested for safety and suited to coloured and chemically treated hair. These are the brand’s statements.
Of the four, this is the entry to read side by side with its own ingredient list, where the sulfonate names sit next to the sulphate free wording. Arata has no stated position on whether sulfonates count as sulphates.
For coloured or chemically treated hair the brand’s own suitability statement is the only guide, and it is a claim like the rest.
Checking a bottle against its list
A bottle can be checked on three points. The first is the opening ingredient lines, for SLS, SLES, ALS and sulfonate names, and the second is the exact product name, since brands sell several shampoos under one range. The third is the wording of the claim, whether a badge, an answer or a system description.
Plum is the plainest example of why the name matters. Three other Plum shampoos use SLES according to its own collection page, so a Plum bottle with a different name falls outside the sulphate free answer.
Where the list shows SLS, SLES or ALS, the sulphate free wording and the list disagree under the Mamaearth definition. Where it shows only sulfonate names, as with Arata, none of the four brands discusses the difference.
Bare Anatomy makes its statement for the whole range, which covers every bottle but gives no hint of what the list contains. Arata labels no single shampoo on its collection page.
Hair concerns the four are positioned for
The four shampoos are positioned for different problems. Plum and Bare Anatomy are both frizz shampoos, Mamaearth’s is for hair fall, and Arata’s is for damaged hair and the scalp.
Those positions come from the brands. A sulphate free label does not by itself say which concern a shampoo addresses, and none of the four brands compares itself with the others.
Plum names avocado oil, argan oil and aloe, and Bare Anatomy names rice protein, hyaluronic acid, coconut milk protein and aloe vera extract. Mamaearth leads with onion seed water and Arata with purified water.
Coloured or chemically treated hair is the case Arata names. For hair fall, Mamaearth is the single shampoo among the four that states that purpose, and it says nothing about frizz.